A Q Methodology-Based Analysis of Experts’ Attitudes towards Obstacles and Challenges of Irrigation Management Transfer to Farmers

Document Type : علمی

Authors

• Hasan Afrakhteh ¹
• Asghar Tahmasebi ¹
• Farhad Azizpour ¹
• Dariush Fatollah Taleghani ²
• Fatemeh Askary Bozayeh ³

¹ Kharazmi University

² Agricultural, Research, Education and Extension Organization

³ Kharazmi university

10.22067/jrrp.v6i1.59270

Abstract

Purpose: Using Q-methodology approach, this study attempts to examine the attitudes of experts towards the barriers and challenges of irrigation management transfer.
Methods: In terms of purpose and research methodology, this study is applied and mixed-method (quantitative-qualitative), respectively. To identify the challenges of irrigation management transfer, Q methodology was used. In the first phase, a questionnaire containing two questions about the barriers and challenges to irrigation management transfer were administered to experts and managers of two organizations involved in agricultural water management. After collecting their views and reviewing internal and external resources, 41 items were derived. In the second phase, 30 participants including 20 managers and experts from Guilan Jihad-Agriculture Organization and Guilan Regional Water Authority, as well as 10 faculty members from Departments of Water, Development and Rural Planning in universities of Guilan and Kharazmy were studied. The participants were selected using purposive sampling method.
Findings: Based on the results, a group of experts with the majority of faculty members believed that organizational and cultural barriers were the most important obstacles to the realization of participatory irrigation management. The second group including executive experts with the majority of Guilan Jihad-Agriculture Organization members mentioned that technical and administrative obstacles had more prominent role than cultural and institutional barriers. Finally, from the perspective of the third group that was relatively smaller than the other two groups, the major challenge in non-realization of participatory irrigation management was rooted in cultural-educational issues.
Limitations: Because this study was conducted in the first half of the year characterized with the peak agricultural activity, access to key managers and experts of Guilan Regional Water Authority was very difficult and time consuming.
Practical implications: Codification of clear and practical guidelines enjoying impressive views of the three groups of stakeholders (Ministry of Energy, Ministry of Jihad-Agriculture and academia) in the field of enforcement mechanisms, consulting, regulatory, determination of duties according to the executive, advisory and monitoring position, and avoiding frequent changes in executive agencies responsible for participatory irrigation management can be helpful in this regard.
Authenticity: To date, several important studies have been conducted in this area, each one being an appropriate guide by itself. Distinguished feature of this study is that it looked at this issue from another perspective and tried to study the problem in a distinct way (Q-methodology) from the point of view of different groups involved to compare the differences of views and to drive distinguished components of the three groups’ standpoints (based on the career status of the respondents).

Keywords

• Irrigation management transfer
• participatory irrigation management
• Q Methodology

---

References

1. Ahmad Ali, J., Abbasi, N., Heidari, N., Khani, J., Hamedi Asl, M. … Narimani, Y. (2010). Investigating the reluctance reasons of farmers in establishing WUAs (Case study: Miyandooab plain). The final report of the research project. The Ministry of Agriculture. [In Persian]

2. Apthorpe, R. (1986). Development policy discourse. Public Administration and Development, 6(4), 377-389.

3. Arun, G., Singh, D. R., Kumarc, S., & Kumard, A. (2012). Canal irrigation management through water user’s associations and its impact on efficiency, equity and reliability in water use in Tamil Nadu. Agric. Econ. Res. Rev, 25, 409–419.

4. Ashena, H. (2015). Water crisis or the crisis of governance. Shargh Newspaper, pp. 40-45. [In Persian]

5. Bezi, K., Khosravi, S., Javadi, M., & Hosseinnezhad, M. (2010). Water crisis in the Middle East: Challenges and solutions. Paper presented at the Fourth International Congress of Islamic World Geographers, Zahedan, Iran. [In Persian]

6. Cave, K. (2012). Exploring the influences of institutions on water governance and management (A first nation case study). Unpublished master's thesis, University of Waterloo, Ontario, Canada.

7. De Loë, R., & Kreutzwiser, R. (2007). Challenging the status quo: The evolution of water governance in Canada. In K. Bakker (Ed.), Eau Canada: The future of Canada's water (pp. 85-103). Vancouver: UBC Press.

8. Eduardo, K. A. (2006). Decentralization puzzles: A political economy analysis of irrigation reform in the Philippine. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, The School of Public and Environmental Affairs and Department of Political Science, Indiana University, Indiana.

9. Facon, T. (2007). Performing irrigation and participatory irrigation management: Lesson from FAO irrigation modernization program. Retrieved 5 July 2016 from www.vncold.vn/Modules/CMS/Upload/13/Documents/...19.../PIMfaconEW.pdf

10. Frederiksen, H. D. (1992). Water resources institutions: Some principles and practices. Washington, DC: The World Bank.

11. Garces-Restrepo, C. D., Vermillion, D. L., Munoz, G., Renault, D., & Samand, M. (2007, May). Irrigation management transfer: Worldwide efforts and results. Paper presented at the 4th Asian Regional Conference of ICID and 10th International Seminar on Participatory Irrigation Management, Tehran, Iran.

12. Garces-Restrepo, C. D., Vermillion, D. L., & Munoz, G. (2007). Irrigation management transfer: Worldwide efforts and results. FAO Water Report No. 32.

13. Ghanaat, M., Mamanpoush, A., & Aghababaie, M. (2013). Investigating observed necessities to start preparatory activities related to participatory irrigation management in Abshar network of Zayanderoud river. Journal of Irrigation and Drainage, 1(7), 1-9. [In Persian]

14. Ghenyan, M., Baradaran, M., Mirzaie, E., Soleimani Harooni, K., & Pasha, S. (2013). Participatory management of agriculture water resources, and the factors affecting it. Journals of Water Research in Agriculture, 27(2), 181-190. [In Persian]

15. Gomo, T., Mudhara, M., & Sensanje, A. (2014). Farmers' satisfac‌tion with the performance of the Mooi river irrigation scheme, KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa. Water SA, 40(3), 1–10.

16. Heidarian, S., & Eslami, M. (2009, February). Exogenous changes in the traditional agriculture management and farming system program structure in irrigation development projects (Case study: Dams and irrigation networks of Balakhanloo). Paper presented at the Second National Conference of Experiences in the Construction of Water Utilities and Irrigation and Drainage Networks, Tehran, Iran. [In Persian]

17. Heidarian, S., Taleshi, M., & Alinezhad, M. (2011). The effects of irrigation management transfer on users' satisfaction and improving the management of irrigation network (Moghan plain). Journal of Irrigation and Drainage, 2(5), 186-192. [In Persian]

18. Heidery, N., Heidarian, S., Hashemi, R., Karamati, M., & Alimohammadi, R. (2009). Socio-economic and policy-institutional discussions on improving the efficiency of agricultural water. The final report of the research project, the Ministry of Agriculture. [In Persian]

19. Hosseini, S., Behjaty Ardekani, B., & Rahmani, S. (2011). Identifying the mentality of people towards Iran's privatization policies (Policies of article 44 of the Constitution). Quarterly of Business Administration Studies, 3(6), 51-74. [In Persian]

20. Huppert, W., Svendsen, M., & Vermillion, D. L. (2001). Governing maintenance provision in irrigation. Eschborn: Deutsche Gesellshaft für Technische Zusammenarbeit.

21. Lemoine, N. R. (). Exploring water governance in northern Saskatchewan: Opportunities for a watershed council (Unpublished master's thesis). University of Saskatchewan,

22. Medema, W., Adamowski, J., Orr, C. J., Wals, A., & Milot, N. (2015). Towards sustainable water governance: Examining water governance issues in Quebec through the lens of multi-loop social learning. Canadian Water Resources Journal/Revue canadienne des ressources hydriques, 40(4), 373-391.

23. Mobareki, M., Zali, M., & Dehnad, R. (2013). Identifying organizational barriers to entrepreneurial behavior in aviation organization of Islamic Republic of Iran, based on Q Methodology. Quarterly of Cultural Management, 11(1), 5-32. [In Persian]

24. Mohammadi Tamary, Z., Ahmadvand, M., & Ghasemi, S. (2013). Farmers' attitudes about changing the cropping pattern of rice to citrus. Iranian Journal of Agricultural Extension and Education, 9(2), 89-106. [In Persian]

25. Mortezanezhad, M., Yaghoobi, J., Sotoodenia, A., & Daghestani, M. (2014). Factors affecting the success of Qazvin irrigation network management transfer to the private sector. Journal of Water Research in Agriculture, 28(1), 183-190. [In Persian]

26. Muchara, B., Ortmann, G., Wale, E., & Mudhara, M. (2014). Collective action and participation in irrigation water management: A case study of Mooi river irrigation scheme in KwaZulu-Natal Province, South Africa. Retrieved from http://www.wrc.org.za

27. Najafi, B., & Shirvanian, A. (2006). Investigating the barriers to the participation of water users in irrigation and drainage networks management. Quarterly of Village and Development, 9(3), 53-75. [In Persian]

28. Oorthuizen, J. (2003). Water, works and wages: The everyday politics of irrigation management reform in the Philippines (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). Wageningen University, the Netherlands.

29. Pahl-Wostl, C. D., Tabara, R., Bouwen, M., Craps, A., Dewulf, … Taillieu, T. (2008). The importance of social learning and culture for sustainable water management. Ecological Economics, 64, 484–495.

30. Perret, S. (2002). Water policies and smallholder irrigation schemes in South Africa: A history and new institutional challenges. Water Police, 4(3), 282–298.

31. Rahimi Feizabad, F., Yazdanpanah, M., Foroozani, M., Mohammadzadeh, S., & Boorten, R. (2014). The relationship between social capital and the willingness of farmers to membership in the WUA (Alashtar). Journal of Agriculture and Cooperatives, 3(12), 76-95. [In Persian]

32. Rogers, P., & Hall, A. (2003). Effective water governance. Retrieved 25 April 2016 from www.gwp.org/.../07%20effective%20water%20governance.

33. Sinha, P. (2014, November). Sustainability issues in participatory irrigation management (PIM) in India. Paper presented at the National Convention of Presidents of Water User Associations organized by MOWR RD & GR, India NPIM at Delhi. Retrieved from wrmin.nic.in/writereaddata/PIM11.pdf

34. Suhardiman, D. (2008). Bureaucratic designs: The paradox of irrigation management transfer in Indonesia. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Wageningen University, The Netherlands.

35. Suhardiman, D. (2013). The power to resist: Irrigation management transfer in Indonesia. Water Alternatives, 6(1), 25-41. Retrieved 30 March 2016 from www.wateralternatives.org/index.php/volume6/v6issue1/197-a6-1-2/file.

36. Teisman, G., Van Buuren, A., Edelenbos, J., & Warner, J. (2013). Water governance: Facing the limits of managerialism, determinism, water-centricity, and technocratic problem-solving. International Journal of Water Governance, 1, 1–11.

37. Van Der Valk, M., & Keenan, P. (2011). Principles of good governance at different water governance levels. Retrieved 30 April 2016 from https://www.unesco.nl/sites/default/files/dossier/water_governance.pdg_.pdf

38. Wang, H. (2013). Challenge and opportunities for source water protection plan implementation in Saskatchewan: Lessons for capacity building. Unpublished master's thesis, University of Saskatchewan,

39. Wester, P. (2008). Shedding the waters: Institutional change and water control in the Lerma-Chapala basin, Mexico. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Wageningen University, The Netherlands.

40. Yaghoobi, J. (2009, May). A model for public participation in water resource management. Paper presented at the Second National Conference on the Effects of Drought and its Management Solutions, Research Center for Agriculture and Natural Resources, Isfahan, Iran. [In Persian]

41. Yousefi, A., Mozafar Amini, A., Yadgari, A., & Fathi, O. (2013, February). Evaluating the sustainable water governance components in Zayanderood river management. Paper presented at the Fifth Conference on Water Resources, Tehran, Iran. [In Persian]