A Survey of the Sense of Spatial Belonging to a Destination Country among Afghan Transnational Immigrants (Case Study: Border Villages in Sistan)

Document Type : علمی

Authors

• Mahmoud Reza MirlotfI ¹
• Hasanali Jahantigh ²

¹ University of Zabol

² Ferdowsi University of Mashhad

10.22067/jrrp.v5i4.64517

Abstract

Purpose- One of the key challenges in the border areas of Sistan is the existence of different ethnic groups and nationalities with different sense of place and identity belonging. The ethnic and national differences has created a turbulent and chaotic landscape in border villages of Sistan and caused a lot of damages to the sense of place and identity in affected areas. Accordingly, the aim of this study was to determine the relationship between the Afghans and the sense of place in the border villages of Sistan.
Design/methodology/approach- The research method is descriptive -analytical and is based on library research and survey. The sample consisted of 31 villages inhabited by Afghans with 3669 households. A sample of 347 households were selected using Cochran's formula and were interviewed based on random sampling. The data were analyzed using the Spearman correlation coefficient in SPSS Software.
Findings- The results of the test show that there is a significant relationship between the number of Afghan residents and sense of place in the studied area with a confidence level of 99 percent, so that by increasing Afghan households, sense of place decreases in the rural area and by reducing households in the rural area, the sense of place will increase. According to the results, it can be expressed that informal settlement of Afghans caused a reduction of sense of place in border villages of Sistan.
Research limitations/implications- One of the restrictions on the way of the research can be lack of accurate statistics on the informal settlers living in the border villages of Sistan. Among the strategies that can be offered to improve regional identity, is a complete identification of the illegal migrants, the setting of firm rules for their control, and the monitoring of the security agencies on immigration.
Practical implications- In order to solve this problem, the exact number of immigrants (illegal) settled in the area should be counted and according to law, they should be either granted citizenship or returned to Afghanistan. In the meantime, the best way is to grant citizenship to immigrants because evidence suggests that the majority of refugees return to their country after being fired from Iran. Accordingly, it is possible to confirm Afghan refugees by granting Iranian citizenship, national identity, and immigration in the destination country (Iran).
Originality/value- So far, no attention to the sense of place of cross-border migrants (Afghans) to Iran, especially in border villages. Nevertheless, the present study has authenticity and practical value. Users of the results of this research are rural and regional planners, provincial government of Sistan and Baluchistan and its departments and agencies under the Department of Afghan citizens in the country.

Keywords

• Informal settlements
• refugees
• sense of place
• Sistan border villages

---

References

1. Bazi, Kh. (1385/2006). Investigating social, cultural, and economic effects of afghan immigrants’ presence in the city of Zabol. Geographic Perspective Quarterly, 3, 23-36. ]in Persian[

2. Dahmardeh, N. (1375/1996). Investigating the causes of Sistan's un-development. Journal of Literature and Human Sciences, 1, 92-111. ]in Persian[

3. European Commission. (2013). Maximizing the development impact of migration. Communication from the commission to the European economic and social committee and the committee of the regions, Brussels, Belgium.

4. Habibi, R. S. (1387/2008). Mental imagery and the concept of place. Journal of Fine Arts, 35, 39-50. ]in Persian[

5. Hafez niya, M. R. (1385/2006). Principles and concepts of geopolitics (1st ed.). Mashhad: Papoli Publications. ]in Persian[

6. Isazadeh, Sh., & Mehranfar, J. (1392/2013). Investigating the impact of international immigration on the level of employment and wage: A case study of Iranian economy. Journal of Economic Research, 103, 11-130. ]in Persian[

7. Javan Forozandeh, A., & Matlabi, G. (1390/2011). The concept of the sense of belonging to the place and its constituent elements. Journal of Urban Identity, 8, 27-37. ]in Persian[

8. Kamalipour. H., Yeganeh. J., & Kearns. A. (2012). People's attachment to place: The influence of neighborhood deprivation. Tehran: Chartered Institute of Housing for the Joseph Row Tree Foundation. ]in Persian[

9. Karimi, Z. (1386/2007). The presence of Afghan refugees in Kashan carpet industry. Journal of Dey Dialogue, 50, 99-116. ]in Persian[

10. Kaviyani Rad, M., & Azizi, K. (1390/2011). The role of place identity in political action (Case study: Enghelab square and Tehran street). Journal of Applied Social Sciences Research, 20, 151-167. ]in Persian[

11. Lewicka, M. (2008). Place attachment, place identity, and place memory: Restoring the forgotten city past. Journal of environmental psychology, 28(3), 209-231. ‏

12. Manzo, L., & Douglas. D. P. (2006). Finding common ground: The importance of place attachment of community participation and planning. Journal of Planning Literature, 20(4), 327- 349.

13. Margasson, R. (2007). Afghan refugees: Current status and future prospects. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, 6, 1-21.

14. Meshkini, A., Ghasemi, A., & Hamzeh Nezhad, M. (1393/2014). The evaluation of the resident's sense of attachment to place in new towns (Case study: Hashtgerd new city). Journal of Geographical Space, 14(48), 41-56. ]in Persian[

15. Mirheydar, D. (1384/2005). The concept of territoriality and its transformation from the point of view of political geography. Journal of Geopolitics, 1(1), 6-18. ]in Persian[

16. Naghdi, A., & Sadeghi, R. (1385/2006). Informal settlement: An obstacle against urban sustainable development. Journal of Social Welfare, 5(20), 213-234. ]in Persian[

17. Pirbabai, M., & Sajadzadeh, H. (1390/2011). Collective membership of the place: Research on social housing in the traditional neighborhood. Journal of Bagh Nazar, 8(16), 17-28. ]in Persian[

18. Pishgami Far, Z., & Akbari, R. (1386/ 2007). Introduction to political geography (1st ed.). Tehran: Tehran University Press. ]in Persian[

19. Statistic Center of Iran. (1390/2011). Results of population and housing census - Hirmand County. Tehran: SCI Publication. ]in Persian]

20. Rezazadeh, R. (1380/2001). Perception – behavioral crisis in urban space. Journal of Municipalities, 23, 1-20. ]in Persian[

21. Rezvan, A., & Fathi, M. (1391/2012). Investigating factors associated with insecurity in urban neighborhoods: District 3 of Tehran's 17th municipality. Journal of Social Welfare, 45, 387-410. ]in Persian]

22. Sarmast, B., & Motevaseli, M. (1389/2010). Investigating and analyzing the role of city scale: A case study of Tehran. Journal of Urban Management, 26, 133-146. ]in Persian[

23. Sholeh, M. (1385/2006). The gates of the past in the collective memory of the contemporary city, the seeking the roots of memory. Journal of Fine Arts, 27, 17-56. ]in Persian[

24. Tavakoli, M. (1388/2009). An analysis of the impact of the sense of spatial belonging of rural Shiite women on immigration in the Sistan region. Quarterly Journal of Shiite Women, 21, 161-184. ]in Persian]

25. Varesi, H. R., Amelbafandeh, M., & Mohamadzadeh, M. (1389/2010). Investigating and analyzing the components of urban identity and its relationship with the place of honor of residents of new towns (Case study: Golbahar city). Journal of Urban Planning and Research, 2, 17-36. ]in Persian[

26. Wickramasekara, P., Sehgal, J., Mehran, F., Noroozi, L., & Eisazadeh, S. (2006). Afghan households in Iran: Profile and impact. International Migration Programme International Labour Office. ‏

27. Zarghani, S. H., & Mousavi, S. Z. (1391/2012). International immigration and national security. Strategic Studies Quarterly, 1, 7-26. [in Persian]

28. Ziyari, K. A., Sharifi, A., & Naimi, K. (1393/2014). Assessment of the role of social development in consolidating spatial sense: A case study of district 10 of Sanandaj city. Journal of Space Geography, 14, 83- 98. ]in Persian]